3 Hidden Tests That Expose a False Victim (Before They Use You)

Jan 22, 2026

Have you ever backed someone with your whole heart… then realized you were drafted into someone else's war?

I mean, the tears were real. The pain sounded real. The story was heartbreaking.

So you defended them. You took their side. You believed every word.

And then one day, you found out the full story. And you realized: you weren't helping a victim. You were being used as a weapon.

Or maybe you're in that situation right now. Someone's come to you with a story, and you want to help. But there's this nagging feeling in your spirit that something is… off. You can't put your finger on it, but the story is a little too perfect. They are the flawless victim. The other person is pure evil.

Here's the truth: manipulators don't just lie. They recruit.

They don't want a referee. They want a soldier.

And the most dangerous part? They sound exactly like real victims.

How to Tell the Difference

So how do you tell the difference? How do you support someone who's genuinely hurting without becoming a pawn in someone else's game?

That's what this article is about.

I'm going to give you:

The 3 tell-tale signs that separate a true victim from a manipulator playing the victim.
The #1 mistake compassionate people make that gets them trapped in someone else's drama.
And a simple, 2-part test you can use to see the true direction of someone's heart—so you can offer support with wisdom instead of getting used.

By the end of this article, you'll be able to spot the difference between a cry for help and a call to arms, so you can be compassionate without becoming a casualty.

A Real-Life Example: The Story of Jim

Let me give you a real-life example. Let’s call him Jim. Jim came to his men’s group leader devastated. His wife, Sarah, had left him three months ago, and he told the group: “I don’t understand. I worked 60 hours a week to give her a beautiful home. I wasn’t perfect, but I never hit her. And she just threw it all away. She abandoned me.”

And of course, the men felt for him. The leader encouraged him to see a counselor, and Jim did.

A few weeks later Jim reported back, “My counselor is amazing. He says I’m dealing with betrayal trauma.”

But then, the counselor asked one simple question that shifted the entire focus from Jim's pain to his potential responsibility: “Jim… what did Sarah say was the reason she left?” Jim said, “She claims I’m controlling and angry, but she’s overly sensitive. I had a stressful job.”

The counselor gently followed up: “Can you think of a time your anger felt scary or controlling to her?” That was the moment of truth. The focus shifted from his pain to his potential responsibility, and for Jim, that was intolerable.

He quit. And this, right here, is where the trajectory showed up. The next week he came to the group and said: “That counselor is biased. He’s taking her side. Honestly, Sarah is unstable. And I need you guys to help me set the record straight—because she’s telling people I’m abusive.”

The leader responded calmly: “I’m sorry you’re hurting. But I’m not going to take sides without understanding the full picture.”

Jim’s tone changed instantly. He got cold. He stopped coming for two weeks. And then the leader started hearing that Jim was telling others, “That men’s group isn’t safe. They support abusive women.”

That’s when the leader realized: the red flag wasn’t Jim’s pain — the pain was real. The red flag was the recruitment. Jim didn’t want healing—he wanted reinforcement.

And that shift right there? That’s the sign most people miss.

This is the mark of a high-functioning, covert manipulator with a victim mentality. Some of these people meet criteria for vulnerable/covert narcissism. But you don’t need a diagnosis to see the pattern. They have learned to mimic the language of pain so perfectly that they can fool even the most discerning people. They use their victimhood as a weapon to recruit allies, isolate their true target, and control the narrative.

And if you fall for it, you become an unwitting participant in their abuse. You become an unwitting ally.

Your Free Gift: The Believer's Guide to Identifying Flying Monkeys

And that term, "unwitting ally," is so important. In the world of toxic relationship dynamics, these are often called "flying monkeys." They are the good-hearted people who get recruited to do the manipulator's bidding, just like the men's group was almost recruited by Jim.

Because this is such a critical piece of the puzzle, I've created a free guide for you called The Believer's Guide to Identifying Flying Monkeys. It will help you spot the tactics manipulators use to recruit allies and give you clear, biblical steps to protect your peace without losing your compassion.

Click Here to Download Your Free Guide Now

The Accountability & Trajectory Test

So how do we avoid this? How do we obey the biblical command to “weep with those who weep” without being deceived? How do we support the wounded without empowering the wicked?

We need a second layer of discernment. We need to go beyond just listening to their story and start gently testing the spirit behind it. And that’s where the Accountability & Trajectory Test comes in.

The Accountability & Trajectory Test is not a one-time interrogation; it’s a series of lenses you use over time to see the pattern of someone’s heart. A manipulator can answer a question correctly once, but they cannot sustain a false posture over time.

Trajectory means this: over time, do they become more grounded and solutions-oriented… or more outraged, more entitled, and more demanding of your loyalty? This test is designed to reveal the true goal of their heart.

A true victim wants a SOLUTION. A false victim wants an ALLY.

Let me say that again. A true victim wants the pain to stop and for things to be made right. A false victim needs the pain to continue, because it keeps everyone in position.

Now, I want to be very clear about something. These are not questions you use to interrogate someone. These are gentle, supportive lenses you use in the context of offering help. You are not trying to catch them in a lie; you are trying to discern the spirit behind their request so you can respond wisely.

Think of it like this: a good doctor takes every symptom seriously. But they don’t diagnose based on symptoms alone. They ask follow-up questions, they run tests, they look for patterns. Not because they don’t care, but because they want to give the right treatment. That’s what we’re doing here. We’re diagnosing the spirit so we can offer the right kind of support.

These three lenses will help you figure out which one you’re dealing with.

Lens #1: Fair Process vs. Control

So, the first lens is all about this question: Do they want a fair process, or do they just want control?

You see, many manipulators don’t actually reject help—they curate it. They don’t want a fair process. They want an authority figure who will crown them “the victim” and help them win the narrative.

A true victim is looking for safe people who can help them find a path to healing. They might be terrified of counseling, especially if they’ve had bad experiences. They might say, "I don’t trust that pastor, they’re too close to my abuser." Those are legitimate safety concerns.

But their trajectory is toward finding the right help. They are open to a process that involves accountability for everyone.

They might say:

"I’m scared of counseling, but do you know someone who specializes in abuse?"
"I’m willing to talk to a pastor, but it needs to be someone who understands power dynamics."

They want a fair process.

A false victim isn’t looking for a fair process; they are looking to control the helper. They don’t want a process; they want a weapon. Their pattern looks like this:

They choose helpers who only hear their version.
They return with “validation receipts.” (“My counselor agrees with me.”)
The first time accountability shows up, the helper becomes ‘unsafe.’
Then they repeat the cycle—new helper, same story.

A true victim can be scared of the process… but they don’t need to control it.

So the question is not, "Are they willing to get help?" The question is, "What happens when the help they’re getting starts to hold them accountable?" A true victim leans in. A manipulator runs away.

Lens #2: Accountability vs. Punishment

Alright, the second lens is about the difference between accountability and punishment. It asks: Are they focused on accountability, or are they focused on punishment?

This one is subtle, but it’s very revealing. Listen to the kind of justice they are seeking over time.

A true victim’s language is centered on wanting the harmful behavior to stop and for the person to be held accountable. They want the person to understand the pain they’ve caused. Even in their pain, their desire is for justice that leads to safety and, if possible, restoration.

They say things like:

"I just wish they would see how much they’re hurting our family."
"I want them to get help. I want them to stop."
"There need to be consequences for this behavior so it doesn’t happen again."

Their focus is on restoration and safety. Even if the relationship cannot be restored, they want the person to get help so they don’t hurt others.

For example, a true victim might say, "I've had to leave for my safety, but I'm praying that the person who hurt me gets the help they need. I don't want them to do this to someone else. I want them to be healed." That is the heart of a true victim.

A false victim’s language is focused on punishment, revenge, and destruction. They are not interested in accountability that leads to change; they are interested in a victory that leads to the other person’s ruin. Justice for them seeks humiliation, exposure, and permanent exile.

Justice seeks protection and proportion. Punishment seeks ruin and humiliation.

They say things like:

"Everyone needs to know what a monster they are. They need to be fired."
"I want to see their life fall apart. They deserve to suffer."
"We need to make sure they are completely and utterly destroyed. They need to pay."

Do you hear the difference? One is a cry for justice and peace. The other is a cry for vengeance. A true victim wants the abuse to stop. A false victim wants the abuser to be annihilated.

Now, let me pause here and say this: if someone has been deeply traumatized, they might, in a moment of pain, express a desire for revenge. That's a normal human emotion. But if that is their consistent, ongoing focus—if every conversation is about how to destroy the other person—that is a red flag. A true victim, even in their pain, will eventually come back to a desire for healing and peace.

Lens #3: Self-Reflection vs. Self-Justification

This brings us to our third and final lens, which asks: Can they engage in self-reflection, or are they stuck in self-justification?

Now, let me be crystal clear: A victim is NEVER responsible for the abuse they have endured. This is not about self-blame. It is about the capacity to look inward without collapsing or attacking.

And just so we’re clear: in an abuse dynamic, the “1%” is usually things like ignoring red flags, staying too long, or responding in fear—not “causing” the abuse.

A true victim, while not at fault for the abuse, can almost always, over time, see their own part in the larger dynamic. They are capable of humility and self-reflection.

They might say:

"I know I shouldn’t have ignored the red flags for so long."
"I can see how my people-pleasing enabled their behavior."
"I know I didn’t handle that last conversation well. I was so angry, and I yelled, and I shouldn’t have done that."

They can own their 1%. This is a mark of a healthy person.

A false victim will show zero capacity for self-reflection. They will present themselves as completely and utterly blameless in every aspect of the conflict. The idea that they might have contributed to the problem in any way, even 1%, is intolerable to them. Manipulators don’t lack insight—they lack tolerance for it.

If you gently ask a question like, "Is there anything you think you could have done differently in that situation?" you will be met with:

Indignant Rage: "How dare you? After everything I’ve told you, you’re taking their side?"
Deflection: "Well, even if I did, it was only because of what they did first."
A Complete Shutdown: They will go cold and withdraw, punishing you for daring to question their perfect victimhood.

This inability to own even the smallest part of the conflict is the clearest sign that you are not dealing with a true victim. You are dealing with a manipulator in disguise.

The Hidden Test: Resisting Premature Judgment

Now, there’s one more hidden test that’s incredibly revealing — and we actually saw it play out in Jim’s story.

Scripture speaks directly to this. Proverbs 18:17 says, “The first to present his case seems right, until another comes and questions him.” And Proverbs 18:13 warns, “To answer before listening — that is folly and shame.”

This is not about neutrality. It’s about wisdom. It’s about refusing to render judgment based on a single narrative — especially when you’re being emotionally recruited.

One of the fastest ways to expose a false victim is to resist premature judgment. When you stop echoing their conclusions and instead take a posture of careful listening — watch what happens.

The men’s group leader modeled this perfectly when he said: “I’m sorry you’re hurting. I take harm seriously. But I’m not going to draw conclusions until I’ve heard the full picture.”

A true victim may feel disappointed. They may desperately want you to stand with them — and that’s understandable. But they will not punish you for seeking truth. Their relationship with you can withstand your wisdom.

A false victim, on the other hand, experiences this as betrayal. If you will not immediately take their side, you become the enemy. They will often escalate, withdraw, or begin discrediting you — because what they wanted was not truth, but allegiance.

That reaction tells you more than the story ever could.

What to Do If You've Been Recruited

So what do you do if you realize you’ve been recruited as an unwitting ally?

Forgive yourself. These manipulators are incredibly skilled. They fool pastors, therapists, and entire communities. You are not foolish for having a compassionate heart.
Quietly withdraw your support. You don’t owe a debate. Don’t confront to expose. Just withdraw your participation. You can say something like, “I’ve realized this situation is more complex than I understood, and I’m no longer comfortable being involved in this way.”
Pray. Pray for wisdom, pray for the true victim, and yes, even pray for the manipulator. The Bible tells us to pray for our enemies, and someone who has to live in a prison of their own making is truly in a desperate state.

And a quick but important safeguard: Real victims may sound chaotic at first. Trauma scrambles people. So we’re not judging a moment—we’re watching a pattern.

Someone can be genuinely hurting—and still be manipulating you.

Summary: The Questions to Ask Yourself

So, to bring it all together, here are the questions you can ask yourself:

Do they want a fair process—or just control?
Do they want protection and accountability—or ruin and revenge?
Can they self-reflect without attacking—or do they collapse into self-justification?
And the hidden tell: what happens when you resist premature judgment?

Support people. But don’t surrender your discernment. Compassion isn’t gullibility.

Toxicity is NOT your destiny.

Downloadable Resources

Want more content like this?

Get encouraging and empowering content delivered straight to your inbox! Join my mailing list to receive weekly blogs and resources.

By filling this form, you agree to receive quality-filled communications from us. We will never spam you or share your information with a third party.